[Story] The Wrong Way To Purchase Workers Comp Insurance

Here is the story of a contracting business that recently called us after receiving a $13,000 worker’s comp audit bill in the mail.

This story should serve as a warning for what can happen when businesses try to DIY (Do-It-Yourself) their worker’s compensation insurance.

Watch below or keep reading…

YouTube player


Reducing Your Insurance Premiums Is Only The Beginning


Our proprietary, RogueRisk365® program puts you in a position to “Win” the insurance game.

By focusing not just on reducing insurance premiums, but Total Cost of Risk, our clients create a sustainable safety culture that cuts costs and frees up cash flow that belongs in their bank account, not with an insurance company. Here are a few of our services:

  • Experience Mod Audit
  • Market Analysis & Placement
  • Premium Audit Review
  • 24/7 HR Hotline
  • Handbook & Document Building
  • e-Learning Platform
  • 24/7 Injury Nurse Triage Hotline

The Wrong Way to Purchase Worker’s Comp

In the case of this business, they made a classic mistake.

The business is owned and operated by a husband and wife. The wife owned the business 100 percent, but wasn’t overly involved in the business operation.

The husband on the other hand was the president and primary driver of the business.

In setting up the worker’s comp insurance, they excluded the wife from coverage, which means they would not pay premiums on the small salary she took for office and clerical work.

They then correctly listed the worker’s comp class code and renumeration for their two employees who did the physical labor of the job and purchased the policy.

At face value, this is all correct.

The mistake that cost them over $13,000 at audit time was not listing the husband on the policy.

Because the husband didn’t take a direct salary and didn’t engage the “main” operations (his words) of the business he didn’t believe that he needed to be part of the worker’s comp policy.

This is not correct.

The husband is technically not an owner so he cannot exclude himself or any remuneration he receives whether it’s a direct salary or not.

Additionally, because they were not keeping detailed payroll records, the husband was charged insurance premium against the average salary of a president of a company similar in size and operations at the most expensive class code.

Download our free eBook: 5 Reasons To Get An Experience Modification Audit

Get a quote

Learn more about our exclusive worker’s comp insurance program to address the unique needs of business owners with employees.

The Solution

The solution is to work with a worker’s compensation specialist when setting up your policy.

In the case of this company, we advised this company on a couple different options:

  1. Moving forward the husband could take an ownership stake in the business. He then could exclude himself from coverage moving forward.
  2. Keep proper payroll records and add the husband to the policy in order to pay accurate premiums against his remuneration over the next policy period.

Unfortunately, there is no course of action to NOT pay the large audit bill this year.

A worker’s comp specialist, like Rogue Risk, will be able to work through your unique situation to find the best worker’s comp insurance company as well as maximize discounts available to you.

As outlined above, a simple error in setting up your policy can have huge ramifications.

No one wants to receive a large premium audit bill at the end of the year.

This is where we come in at Rogue Risk.

We’re workers compensation specialists and can help you navigate market and workforce changes to make sure you have the coverage you without being overcharged.

You can start with a free Workers Comp Experience Mod Audit, or you can use the options below to get a quote today!

I look forward to introducing you to a new way of viewing your insurance program.

Thank you,

Ryan Hanley

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Start a Quote in Minutes

Click the button below to receive a custom-tailored insurance quote to fit your budget and need.

More Articles


(855) 960-6600

24 4th Street, Troy, NY 12180

Scroll to Top